Prosper Capital: Moving From Reactive Tasks to Proactive Performance
Prosper Capital
Established: 2020
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio
Portfolio: Multifamily, Single-Family, Commercial
Units Under Management: 460+ Units
After hitting the limits of their previous solution, Prosper Capital needed more structure, automation, and insight to grow. See how partnering with AppFolio gave Prosper Capital a unified system and tools to reduce operational headaches, enabling them to manage hundreds of units and focus on delivering exceptional resident experiences.
Tenant Cloud
100%
1 Hour Per Delinquent Resident, Per Month
“Without AppFolio, we wouldn’t have been able to scale. AppFolio has taken us from 75 units to nearly 500, with plans to reach 1,000 — and we still see it as the system of record that allows us to get larger and larger without having to recreate the wheel.”
Redefining Real Estate
Based in Cincinnati, DJ entered real estate 11 years ago, buying a single-family home straight out of college. What started as a single investment quickly evolved into a high-performing property management operation. Today, he serves as Owner, Operator, and Founder of Prosper Capital (a real estate investment firm) and Prosper Communities (its management arm). Prosper operates primarily as an owner-operator, not a third-party manager, which is a distinction that shapes how the company defines performance.
Prosper’s 15-person team oversees nearly 500 units, primarily multifamily, with a small mix of single-family, commercial, and short-term rentals, all within a 30-mile radius of Cincinnati. DJ and his team approach property management differently: Scale alone isn’t the goal; performance is. DJ has built Prosper on a simple belief: When you elevate the experience, performance follows.
“We think of ourselves more like a boutique hotel experience than the traditional ‘pay your rent on the first and talk to you later’ model. It’s about creating a better service, and that’s something that’s unprecedented in the marketplace."
A Platform Built to Scale
Like many owners, DJ started with basic software, and the priority was simple: collect rent, track the essentials, and keep operations moving. At the time, it supported that stage of growth, providing him with a starting framework for managing a small portfolio without overcomplicating things. As Prosper sought to evolve into a structured company with employees, in-house services, and long-term ambitions, the limitations of that solution became harder to ignore.
“When I first started, our previous solution was a great resource at the size we were at. It helped me collect rent and standardize some processes, but it was essentially just a shell. It didn’t have the muscle behind it.”
If Prosper wanted to begin its next chapter, DJ knew that technology had to mature alongside his business. When it was time to upgrade, he didn’t rush the decision. He evaluated major players, comparing features, costs, and long-term fit across platforms such as Buildium, Yardi, and Rent Manager. Price mattered, especially as a growing operator, but performance mattered more.
“It wasn’t a rash decision, and I looked at all the pros and cons between AppFolio, Buildium, Yardi, Rent Manager, and everything in between. The one thing I found, and why I ultimately decided on AppFolio, was the user experience — both on the resident side and as an employee working on the backend. It felt like fewer clicks and easier to get things done.”
Switching Without Slowing Down
When DJ committed to switching to AppFolio, the timeline moved quickly. Rather than a distant next step, onboarding was scheduled within days, not months. Change at that scale can feel disruptive, but what stood out wasn’t the speed of the transition; it was how controlled it felt.
“I was very hesitant to change because of all the moving pieces I felt that had to move at once. I remember the onboarding team saying, ‘We’re starting next month,’ and I’m thinking about switching residents over, and wondering if this is going to impact anything. But we met multiple times, and it was a seamless experience overall. We basically had zero hiccups during the transition. Residents were moved to the new platform, and we didn’t miss a beat.”
What could have felt overwhelming on paper played out differently in practice. Through structured checklists, guided sessions, and multiple touchpoints, AppFolio guides the onboarding process with clarity and control. This type of continuity mattered for Prosper. For a company built around experience and responsiveness, any disruption would have been noticeable. Instead, the rollout to AppFolio reinforced the operational discipline DJ wanted to build.
“Usually, no resident is good with change. But the minimal friction and minimal calls we got about migrating to AppFolio showed that it was very seamless. Being able to deploy a text message with a link to residents to set up their account helped. If there was friction, it was to help the less tech-savvy residents. But outside of that, there weren’t many issues.”
Built-In Performance at Every Touchpoint
From accounting and work orders to resident communication and automated workflows, DJ and his team rely on AppFolio to streamline day-to-day management and ensure nothing falls through the cracks. Every feature is a tool to maintain efficiency, protect residents, and give the team the clarity to perform at a high level.
System of Record
“A property management business is basically a CPA or accounting firm because 90% of the work is accounting. We use AppFolio as our system of record, so if it’s not in AppFolio, it doesn’t exist. Everything we do — from GL accounts to work orders and residents notes — runs through AppFolio, making sure we’re tracking accurately and protecting our residents.”
Mastering Maintenance
“Our techs can document each work order with pictures and notes, so we have a detailed record of exactly what happened. It’s not just for internal tracking. It’s proof we delivered on our promises and a tool to resolve any questions or disputes with residents. We’re proud to say that our average work order completion time is approximately 24 hours.”
Automation That Amplifies
“We rely on AppFolio Realm-X Flows to fill in the gaps and to automatically push communications to our residents. We use the Rent Reminder Flow and it’s a huge timesaver. The system automatically sends texts and emails, and we don’t touch it unless we have to print notices.
Renewals work the same way. Once the manual setup is done, it’s hands-off, only prompting us at 100 days and 30 days. Outside of that, it just runs itself. We’re moving more tasks over to Realm-X to let it handle the heavy lifting for us.”
The AppFolio DifferenceAI as an Extension of the Team
At Prosper, AI has shifted the team from a task-based approach to a performance-driven mindset, letting them focus on meaningful interactions rather than repetitive checklists. DJ sees the agentic AI capabilities in AppFolio as an extension of his team, handling frontline questions and efficiently routing prospects or residents to the right person so the team spends less time reacting and more time delivering results.
“By no means do I see AI replacing individuals. I just see it as an extension of really efficient team members. It’s able to provide prospects and residents with the information faster, just like they want. Rather than feeling like we’re reacting, we’re using AI to do more of the preventative work.”
Having AI fully native within AppFolio means everything communicates through a single system. Tasks, resident requests, and follow-ups are automatically routed to the appropriate team member. By automating routine interactions, his team can engage in more strategic conversations, elevate the resident experience, and drive true business performance — all without adding unnecessary systems or complexity.
“Our preference is fewer systems if we can. So we will do anything that we can to try to avoid getting more and more systems. Because AI is integrated in AppFolio, it can answer the questions based on the information that we have in the system because it’s all in there.”
Performance Powered by AppFolio
For DJ, performance at Prosper goes far beyond spreadsheets and KPIs and drills down to the human experience. Success is measured not just in revenue or completed tasks but in the satisfaction of residents and the clarity of team operations. DJ credits AppFolio for playing a critical role in powering that performance.
“AppFolio has really given us the ability to export the data and normalize it so they’re not numbers on a spreadsheet. Having the ability to export just about any data point in almost any way allows us to look at the data in multiple ways.”
With a single, accurate system of record, DJ’s team can track historical trends, onboard new employees quickly, and anticipate future needs, all while delivering consistent, high-quality experiences.
“Having all of our data in AppFolio is the only way performing will be possible. If it were in multiple databases, it would be impossible for anyone to have the real-time data and business history. AppFolio is instrumental in helping us scale.”
What Real Performance Looks LikeGrowing Together to Create What’s Next
For DJ, the partnership with AppFolio goes far beyond a typical software relationship. It’s a partnership that’s collaborative, dynamic, and forward-looking and helps shape the future of property management while optimizing Prosper’s day-to-day operations.
“I always want to poke around with the latest products, and I tell AppFolio members, ‘Hey, I want to see what the next technology is.’ That’s allowed me to beta-test what’s next and give feedback. AppFolio encourages sharing challenges, collaborating, and helping shape future tools in their platform.”
Powering the Future With a Performance Platform
As Prosper enters a new stage of growth, DJ is thinking big. His five-year vision calls for expanding Prosper Communities from 460 units to 2,000 units by 2030 and broadening into multiple Midwest markets, all while maintaining the boutique service experience that sets the company apart. Central to that vision is AppFolio. Every process, SOP, and policy is built around the platform, creating a seamless framework for team members and residents alike.
“AppFolio is the backbone of building out our processes. We build every system around how it works in AppFolio to make sure that the process is seamless. AppFolio has allowed me to get out of the day-to-day and start thinking of the future. I have the chance to set better work hours, spend time with my wife and family, golf, and give back to the real estate community.*”
DJ Humes
Owner, Operator, and Founder, Prosper Capital, 460+ Units
Why Take Our Word for It?
See what AppFolio
can do for you
can do for you
Your success is our passion. Whether it’s onboarding, support, or strategic advice, product
experts are on call to answer your questions.